哈特“内在观点”的康德伦理学之维
-
摘要: 哈特对法律规则关注的视角从"坏人观点"转向"内在观点",在研究方法上实现了诠释学转向,从而完成了法学领域的一次"哥白尼式革命"。"内在观点"类似于康德哲学中的"自律",持"内在观点"的人对待法律是"出于义务";"坏人观点"类似于康德哲学中的"他律",持"坏人观点"的人对待法律可能"合乎义务",但非"出自义务"。"内在观点"的表达方式是"定言命令",而"坏人观点"的表达方式是"假言命令"。
-
-
[1]
Dale A Nance.Rules,standards and the internal point of view[J].Fordham Law Review,2006(75):1293.
-
[2]
Scott J Shapiro.What is the internal point of view?[J].Fordham Law Review,2006(75):1160.
-
[3]
Ronald Dworkin.Law's Empire[M].Cambridge,Massachusetts:Harvard University Press,1986:13-14.
-
[4]
陈景辉.法律的界限:实证主义命题群之展开[M].北京:中国政法大学出版社,2007:66-68.
-
[5]
陈锐,李建新.法律实证主义的多重转向[J].重庆大学学报:社会科学版,2010(4):90.
-
[6]
Scott J Shapiro.Legality[M].Cambridge,Massachusetts:The Belknap Press of Harvard University Press,2011:111-113.
-
[7]
Steven J Burtoned.The Path of the Law and its Influence:The Legacy of Oliver Wendell Holmes,Jr[M].Cambridge:Cambridge University Press,2000.
-
[8]
Edward White G.Getting close to Herbert Hart[J].Melbourne University Law Review,2005(29):324.
-
[9]
Amanda Perreau-Saussine.An outsider on the insider:Hart's limits on jurisprudence[J].University of Toronto Law Journal,2006(56):372.
-
[10]
李泽厚.批判哲学的批判:康德述评[M].北京:生活·读书·新知三联书店,2007:304.
-
[11]
范立波.论法律规范性的概念与来源[J].法律科学,2010(4):23.
-
[12]
Stephen Perry.Hart on social rules and the foundations of law:Liberating the internal point of view[J].Fordham Law Review,2006(75):1172.
-
[1]
-
点击查看大图
计量
- PDF下载量: 36
- 文章访问数: 1045
- 引证文献数: 0
下载:
